Investigate your researchers who packaged poor, misleading security, human rights report on Nigeria, Former Senate President writes US President Trump
“And Nigerians can testify to several instances where the Army leadership penalised soldiers found to have indulged in professional misconducts and human rights abuses of Nigerians. Sir, it is my firm conviction that the contents of the US Department of State titled, “2018 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices,” are misplaced. I believe strongly that the researchers were misled into crafting the report based on speculative assumptions to erode the credibility of the FGN, the Nigerian Army and other security agencies.”
A former Nigeria’s Senate President, Chief Ameh Ebute, has written to the United States President Donald Trump over the recent report by the US Department of State titled “2018 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices.”
In the report, the American government accused the Federal Government of Nigeria and state agents, particularly, the Nigerian military, of arbitrary and unlawful killings and an array of other sundry crimes bordering on human rights violations allegedly perpetrated in the country in the year under review.
Ebute, the letter entitled “Time To Break off The Disintegration Of Nigeria: An Open Letter”, on Thursday, reportedly urged the US government to “investigate the researchers who packaged the report and apply appropriate sanctions on them for official ineptitude as advertised by the poor job.”
Ebute said he was encouraged as “an elder citizen and leader in Nigeria to write the open letter in order to correct certain erroneous impressions and strengthen the records on the punchy assault on the human rights direction of the incumbent leadership of the Federal Government of Nigeria (FGN) under President Muhammadu Buhari, and the Nigerian Military, especially the Nigerian Army.”
The letter
The letter read in part: “My motivation for this open epistle is energised by a report recently released through the US Department of State titled, “2018 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices.” In the report, the American Government accused the FGN and state agents, particularly, the Nigerian Army, of arbitrary and unlawful killings and an array of other sundry crimes bordering on human rights violations allegedly perpetrated in our country in the year under review.
“First, let me commend the friendly interest of the US Government in the affairs of Nigeria. It is a demonstration of the finest pursuit of the global agenda of upholding human dignity, peace, unity and security of nations of the world. I dare say, Nigeria relishes the good and smooth diplomatic ties with America in the last few years and believe it will further deepen in the years ahead.
“I accept in totality that the US “2018 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices,” is one of the many ways the American government keeps independent nations around the world on their toes, foster global communism, respect for human dignity and the fundamental human rights of all races of the world.”
Continuing, it read: “However, I believe certain assumptions as contained in the report on Nigeria, which hinged on human rights violations by the Nigerian Army, did not reflect the reality in our country under the Buhari Presidency. We must first acknowledge that Nigeria is facing one of its toughest times in history, since independence.
Security issues
“With an array of threatening insecurity issues ranging from Boko Haram terrorism to other insurrectional uprisings and near senseless agitations, our country has been on the cliffhanger to say the least. It is glaring to all Nigerians that the veiled and open plots to destabilise Nigeria and possibly cause its disintegration spearheaded by internal actors is actively backed by foreign forces.
It further read: “The gang-up against Nigeria to cause its break-up is strong, thick, scary and penetrative, as reflected in the barrage of existing and emerging insecurity threats across the country.
“Our military, especially the Nigerian Army, are overstretched in efforts to contain the pervading terrorism and insurrections. But the Nigerian Army under the leadership of the Chief of Army Staff (COAS) Lt. Gen. Tukur Yusufu Buratai, who also doubles as the leader of the counter-insurgency operations in Nigeria have been the saving grace and they have never flinched.
“It is needless to chronicle the steadfastness and sacrifices the Army as an institution and our soldiers has made in the last three years to anchor the relative peace and security we savour today in the country. We are proud of them for repressing our foes.”
Debt of gratitude
The former president of the Senate also said in the letter that: “We owe them a debt of gratitude; Nigerian soldiers deserve our collective applause for the wonderful outings, especially against Boko Haram insurgency.
“However, external enemies of Nigeria in league with devious internal allies are saddened by the unbreakable patriotism, loyalty and commitment of our troops to the cause of the emancipation of Nigeria, by mounting an effective, impenetrable and strong bulwark against these dark agents of destabilisation and break-up of Nigeria.
“Therefore, it is common knowledge that they have conspired to break the resolve of the Nigerian Army in winning the war against terror and insurrections. They have deployed various antics, including, but not restricted to false accusations of the Army on human rights violations, smear campaigns and outright vilification of the institution of the Nigerian Army to dampen the fighting spirit of soldiers and weaken their morale. But these gimmicks have failed to post the results the detractors expect.”
“The Nigerian Army under the leadership of Gen. Buratai has always held itself accountable to the people and government of Nigeria. In all operations of soldiers, especially in the Northeast, the Army leadership has always ensured compliance with international best practices in observing human rights obligations and rules of engagement.”
Gen. Buratai’s initiative
He also noted in the letter that: “Your Excellency, it may interest you to know that the Nigerian Army under the leadership of Gen. Buratai has set up the Human Rights Desk in Army Headquarters,’ Abuja. It is the first of its kind since the establishment of the Nigerian Army. “And its mandate is to pry into cases of alleged human rights violations of Nigerians by Army personnel. The Human Rights Desk is replicated in all Army Divisions in the country for ease of access.
“An Army leadership with such disposition cannot be adjudged as courting human rights abuses. And truly, no innocent Nigerian citizen has been killed by either the military or any other security agencies without the appropriate sanctions.
“And for the first time since the inception of the Nigerian Army, court summons are served soldiers by aggrieved litigants and the Army appears in court to defend allegations against their personnel. It is a remarkable departure from the tradition of the past, known to us, when soldiers were untouchable or never submitted themselves to lawful institutions for public trial.”
“Furthermore, the Presidency also constituted a Presidential Panel of Inquiry to probe the same allegations and or, review compliance of the armed forces with human rights obligations and rules of engagement. It was chaired by a distinguished jurist, Justice Biobele A. Georgewill. I attended one of the sittings of the panel in Abuja, I found it strange, the discovery that Amnesty International’s published the report on alleged rights abuses against soldiers in the Nigeria’s North-east without visiting Maiduiguri, the epicenter of the reported human rights violations.
President Buhari’s efforts
“I have no doubt that President Buhari has placed the security of lives and property of Nigeria paramount on his list of priorities and monitors security agents over rights abuses of Nigerians. And despite the overwhelming presence of soldiers drafted to assist civil security in virtually all the 36 states of the federation, there are fewer reported cases of human rights violations or undignified treatment of civilians by soldiers on special assignments.
“And Nigerians can testify to several instances where the Army leadership penalised soldiers found to have indulged in professional misconducts and human rights abuses of Nigerians.
“Sir, it is my firm conviction that the contents of the US Department of State titled, “2018 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices,” are misplaced. I believe strongly that the researchers were misled into crafting the report based on speculative assumptions to erode the credibility of the FGN, the Nigerian Army and other security agencies.
“I submit that the contents were not fair, truthful and completely in dissonance with the reality in Nigeria. I urge the US Government to investigate the researchers who packaged the report and apply appropriate sanctions on them for official ineptitude as advertised by the poor job.”
EFCC speaks
In a related development, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has described the report as “false and misleading.”
The commission in a press statement Thursday in Abuja, said: “The attention of the EFCC has been drawn to a misleading report of the United States Department of Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labour over Nigeria’s anti-graft war, published in ThisDay Newspaper of March 17, 2019, entitled: “Nigeria: Massive, Pervasive Corruption At All Levels of Govt – US Report.”
The anti-graft body, however, said the report was “unfounded on the grounds of Nigeria’s remarkable achievements in the last four years as the war against corruption is on course.”
“The EFCC’s commitment to the fight against corruption in the last four years is not in doubt to any discerning and genuinely concerned observer. This commitment is benchmarked by the unprecedented record of convictions, non-conviction based forfeiture and stolen assets recovery.
“We are surprised that the US report could ignore or downplay our convictions in such a brazen manner when it claimed that the EFCC secured only 13 convictions in 2016. That is false and far from the truth.”
